Principal sent Mifflin students to charter
Records show Mifflin High School leadership facilitated enrollment for students at Early College Academy while the district considered closing the building.
By Blake Mitchell ·

Principal Joe Krabill of Mifflin High School actively encouraged students to leave the public system for a charter school, according to emails obtained through public records requests. The correspondence, dated between September 2025 and May 2026, shows Krabill directing students to Early College Academy while the district evaluated the high school for closure.
Mifflin High School is located on the northeast side of Columbus and appears on the district's latest list of schools slated for potential closure. The building is described as a standard educational facility, though the principal’s actions raised questions about the district's intent to retain its student population. Students at the school have organized a petition to save their campus from being shut down.
The records indicate that Krabill maintained ongoing contact with Josh Johnson, the principal and dean of students at Early College Academy. Beyond initial emails, Krabill made phone calls regarding specific students and sent birth certificates and transcripts to the charter school. He also informed Johnson when he could expect the students to arrive, a process that suggests he assisted with or completed the charter school applications for the pupils.
Columbus City Schools administration and the Board of Education have cited under-enrollment as the primary reason for the closure recommendations. However, the direct recruitment of students by a public school principal to a charter competitor complicates the narrative of natural enrollment decline. District officials have also pointed to a $50 million budget deficit as a secondary factor, although the district has not publicly tracked the specific cost savings associated with closing schools.
State legislation is also influencing the closure timeline. Senate Bill 311, sponsored by Senator Andrew Brenner, would require public schools operating below 60 percent of capacity to close. The bill has not yet passed, and it is not currently on the agenda for the House Education Committee. The state legislature is scheduled to convene later this month, with the bill potentially advancing during the lame duck session.
The Columbus Board of Education has not issued a formal response to the specific emails between Krabill and Early College Academy. The district continues to process the closure list while the new state administration, led by Governor Dr. Amy Acton, prepares to address budgetary pressures in the spring 2027 budget cycle.






