AdvertiseDonate
Saturday, November 21, 2026Local news for Providence and Rhode Island.
Providence Tribune · 10 Dorrance Street, Suite 700, Providence, RI 02903
Politics · Denver

Colorado Pension Board: Investment Bonus Caps Reduced

The PERA board voted 11-5 to lower the maximum incentive pay for top investment staff from 225% to 150% of their base salaries, aiming to appease state lawmakers and retirees.

By Julian Vargas ·

Illustration for: Colorado Pension Board: Investment Bonus Caps Reduced
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

The Colorado Public Employees' Retirement Association board voted 11-5 on Friday to implement stricter limits on bonuses for its investment staff. The new compensation policy caps the maximum incentive pay for top investment officials at 150% of their base salaries, a reduction from the previous cap of 225%. Lower-level investment analysts will now earn incentives between 50% and 100% of their salaries, down from the prior range of 75% to 150%.

Board member Tina Mueh, a retired schoolteacher, described the decision as a preemptive measure. She stated, "We are not doing this in a vacuum. This is a preemptive move." Mueh and other board members expressed concern that the state legislature would intervene and cut the incentive program further if the board did not act voluntarily.

The vote responds to pressure from state lawmakers and PERA members following a June investigation by The Colorado Sun. That report found that PERA paid investment staff millions of dollars in bonuses, with some amounts reaching three times their base pay. The previous policy, adopted in 2018, required compensation to be higher than 75% of a peer group that included top public pensions and private sector firms.

PERA executive director Andrew Roth said the new plan aligns the organization's pay with the top quartile of public pensions while moving away from competing aggressively with private sector pay. He described the new position as "comfortably aligned with our peer group." Roth noted that the new structure will place PERA ahead of some public funds but behind others.

Several board members opposed the changes, arguing that lower bonuses could trigger a loss of key personnel. PERA officials state that managing assets internally saves the fund approximately $100 million compared to using outside firms. Andrew Schremp, a board member who works in private equity and voted against the proposal, said, "I'll be blunt: I don't like this at all. I don't even know why we're having this discussion."

Roth explained that without the board's action, PERA would have been required to pay bonuses of up to 677% of salary under the old policy. That total compensation package would have cost $32 million, which is $8 million more than the amount approved on Friday. Roth noted that the current largest U.S. pension, CalPERS, caps investment bonuses at 270% of salary.

Scott Simon, a board member and chief investment officer for the state's firefighter and police pension, argued that the changes risked losing investment talent over relatively small amounts of money. He said PERA was "pennywise and pound foolish" and added, "The current model's working. And if we're unique, maybe we embrace that uniqueness."

The new policy grants the board the authority to defer bonuses for 12 months if investment returns are negative, though it does not allow for their elimination. Secure PERA, a coalition of unions and retiree groups, had requested the ability to eliminate bonuses in years when the fund failed to meet its 7.25% assumed rate of return. State Sen. Chris Kolker has also proposed banning bonuses entirely in years when PERA loses money.

Karen Wick, program manager for Secure PERA, told the board that members expect the system to work hard on their behalf. She said, "That means ensuring that the board has the authority and discretion to exercise strong and credible oversight when the fund is not meeting its financial obligations."

PERA provides retirement benefits to more than 700,000 teachers, state workers, and local government employees. Roth told the board at a Thursday budget hearing that he does not expect a mass exodus of staff. He added that the new policy allows staff to return to the board if recruitment problems arise in the future.

More Politics · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Providence Tribune in your inboxLocal news for Providence and Rhode Island. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Providence Tribune in your inboxLocal news for Providence and Rhode Island. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.